Sitting vs Standing Desks: Which One is Better for Your Back?
Updated: Mar 21
Chronic discomfort in the back is a common problem that afflicts many of my clients, particularly those who spend prolonged periods sitting or slouching in front of their computer monitors. If you're one of these people, you might be curious about which alternative is better for your back's well-being: sitting desks or standing desks? While standing desks have grown in popularity as a potential remedy for reducing back pain, the discussion continues as to whether sitting desks are still more comfortable and practical. However, the answer isn't as simple as it seems. To find out which choice is best for you, we'll have to delve deeper into the benefits and drawbacks of both sitting and standing desks. So, sit tight (or stand tall!) and let's examine the upsides and downsides of each alternative.
The Health Dangers of Prolonged Sitting
Sitting has become a customary part of modern life, especially in office settings. However, excessive sitting can result in various health hazards. One of the most common health issues linked with prolonged sitting is back pain. Sitting for extended periods strains your back muscles, especially if you don't maintain correct posture, causing stiffness, pain, and even chronic back problems.
Moreover, sitting for long periods increases the risk of heart disease. Regardless of regular exercise, sitting for more than six hours a day can lead to poor blood circulation, high blood pressure, and cholesterol levels, increasing the risk of cardiovascular disease.
Another significant health risk of prolonged sitting is obesity. Sitting for long periods slows down metabolism, making it easier to gain weight, leading to other health issues such as diabetes, high blood pressure, and heart disease.
Although regular exercise is essential for good health, it does not entirely counteract the adverse effects of prolonged sitting. Frequent breaks and movement throughout the day, particularly in a desk job, help improve blood circulation and decrease the health risks associated with sitting.
The Debate Over Standing Desks
Standing desks have gained popularity as a potential solution to the health risks of prolonged sitting. However, like any other desk, standing desks have their own advantages and disadvantages.
One of the primary benefits of standing desks is that they reduce the amount of time spent sitting. Standing engages muscles and burns more calories than sitting, and it can help maintain better posture and reduce the risk of developing back pain.
However, standing for prolonged periods can lead to foot, knee, and lower back pain and increase the risk of developing varicose veins. Research on the benefits and drawbacks of standing desks is mixed. Some studies suggest that they improve overall health by reducing the risk of obesity, type 2 diabetes, and cardiovascular disease. Other studies have found no significant health benefits associated with standing desks.
While movement is good for health, standing for too long can have negative consequences. People who switch to standing desks should take frequent breaks, move around and stretch their muscles to avoid the risk of injury.
The Best of Both Worlds: Sit-Stand Desks
Sit-stand desks, also known as height-adjustable desks, offer the best of both worlds and could be a solution for those who are undecided between sitting and standing desks. They allow the user to switch between sitting and standing positions with ease, and the desk's height can be adjusted to accommodate both positions.
One of the significant benefits of sit-stand desks is the ability to alternate between sitting and standing positions, which promotes better circulation, prevents muscle fatigue, and reduces the risk of back pain or other musculoskeletal disorders associated with prolonged sitting or standing. Studies also show that standing for a brief period increases energy expenditure, which can reduce the risk of obesity and related health issues, improves posture, reduces the risk of developing cardiovascular disease, and improves overall mental health.
Compared to traditional sitting or standing desks, sit-stand desks have become increasingly popular in recent years due to their potential health benefits. They offer a more comfortable alternative to standing desks that do not have the option to sit, and they promote more movement than sitting desks, which encourage a sedentary lifestyle.
However, using a sit-stand desk does not automatically result in improved health. It is essential to use the desk correctly, alternate between sitting and standing positions regularly, and maintain proper posture throughout the day. Additionally, it is recommended to gradually increase the time spent standing, as standing for too long can cause discomfort and negative health effects.
Exercise Desks: Treadmill and Bicycle Desks
Exercise desks, which allow individuals to work while walking on a treadmill or cycling on a stationary bike, have become increasingly popular among health-conscious office workers. Moving while working offers a unique benefit of improving physical activity levels while working. However, they are not a perfect solution for everyone. It's important to consider your individual needs and limitations before investing in an exercise desk. If you are interested in trying one out, consider starting with short sessions and gradually increasing your activity level over time.
Tips for a Healthy Workstation
Whether you choose a sitting desk, standing desk, sit-stand desk, or exercise desk, there are some general tips you can follow to promote a healthier workstation.
First, make sure your desk is set up correctly. This means adjusting your chair and desk to ensure your arms are at a comfortable angle, your feet are flat on the floor, and your eyes are level with the top of your monitor.
Second, take frequent breaks to stretch and move around. Even if you have a sit-stand or exercise desk, it's still important to take regular breaks to avoid muscle fatigue and stiffness.
Third, practice good posture. This means sitting or standing up straight, with your shoulders relaxed and your back supported. Avoid slouching or hunching over your desk, as this can lead to back pain and other health issues.
Finally, consider adding some ergonomic accessories to your workstation. This might include a footrest, wrist rest, or monitor arm to help reduce strain on your body.
By following these tips and choosing a workstation that suits your needs, you can help reduce the health risks associated with prolonged sitting or standing and promote a healthier, more productive workday.